| Ruler | Kingdom | Era |
|---|---|---|
| Mr. Defeat of Supernatural Mayhem | Disney Psychos | 47 |
| Mr. Defeat of Supernatural Mayhem | Obscenities from Space | 47 |
| Mr. Supernatural | Ghost Killaz | 33 |
| Mr. Supernatural | 47 | |
| Electric Supernatural Feline | WTF | 47 |
| Sir Supernatural Mayhem | Legacy | 47 |
| Sir Supernatural Mayhem | Legacy | 47 |
| Sir Supernatural Mayhem | Legacy | 47 |
| Sir Supernatural Mayhem | Equilibrium | 48 |
| Sir Supernatural Mayhem | 48 | |